Lashes can transform a look, and choosing the right mascara is essential for achieving length, definition, and longevity. This article compiles practical guidance on selecting mascaras, preventing smudging, and supporting lash health, drawing on expert tips and real-user experiences to help you find a routine that works for your unique lashes.
How to choose the right mascara for your lashes
Everyone's lashes are different, and the best mascara for your best friend may not be right for you. For example, some Allure editors prefer volumizing mascaras for a more dramatic look, while others prefer a curling mascara to lift straight lashes sky-high. Either way, some key factors we kept in mind while making this list include the longevity and pigment of each formula. Our favorites offer length and definition that won’t budge, no matter what your day holds.
Considerations at a glance
- Length and definition: Look for formulas described as lengthening or providing precise separation.
- Longevity: Seek long-wearing claims that resist smudging through day-to-day activities.
- Color payoff: Rich pigments enhance impact and intensity.
- Formula type: Decide between volumizing, curling, or lengthening based on desired outcome.
Waterproof mascara: formulation and wear
The difference between regular and waterproof formulas is whether or not they can withstand rain, tears, or sweat. Cosmetic chemist Ginger King told Allure that ingredients like isododecane (a solvent), paraffin (a type of mineral oil that resists water), and VP/eicosene copolymer (a film-forming agent) are the typical players in waterproof mascara. Since waterproof mascaras are made to handle anything from a light splash to full-on submersion, they can be a little more difficult to wash off at the end of the day. It's best to use a cleansing oil or cleansing balm to dissolve the formula without rubbing or tugging on the skin around your delicate eye area. Still, if your eyes or lashes are particularly sensitive, a tubing mascara that comes off easily with just warm water may be a better option.
Preventing mascara from smudging and flaking
It's always a bummer when a perfectly applied makeup look becomes a mess because of your mascara, but you don't have to suffer through smearing. Instead, follow these smudge-defying tips from New York City-based makeup artist Neil Scibelli.
- Less is more: remove excess formula off of the wand before applying to lashes to get a smooth, even first coat.
- When in doubt, go waterproof: if tears are a concern, switch to a waterproof formula, or seal with a second coat of waterproof mascara.
- Dry-down time: wait until each coat is fully dry before applying the next coat to ensure a clump-free finish.
- Be thorough: comb the back of the lashes with the wand to work through any clumps and separate lashes for a smoother result.
Meet the experts and testing approach
Ginger King, a cosmetic chemist; Neil Scibelli, a New York City-based makeup artist; and additional reporting by Jennifer Hussein, Christa Joanna Lee, and Annie Blackman contribute to expert insights and testing perspectives. Our testing involves a range of editors, writers, contributors, and experts, evaluating efficacy, ease of use, and value across different lash types and concerns. We emphasize a diverse range of testers to fairly assess products for various audiences.
How to apply mascara for best results
- Remove excess mascara from the tip of the wand.
- Begin by applying mascara to the middle of your lashes, at the base, moving in slow, outward, angled strokes.
- Wait for your upper lashes to dry before applying mascara to your lower lashes.
- Apply a second coat if you want more volume, but avoid overloading to prevent clumps.
- If you’re using natural lashes, you may need only light coats; for extensions, follow specific guidelines provided by your lash artist.
Lash health, nutrition, and growth considerations
Your lashes grow in phases and are influenced by heredity and health. Pro peptides are small chains of amino acids that support healthy hair growth. A balanced diet with lean protein, vitamin A, biotin, folic acid, iron, and calcium can help support lash growth from within. In addition to diet, choosing products that nourish and hydrate lashes can promote healthier growth. Some users report long-term results from lash serums, such as Neulash, though results vary by individual. Always consult with a professional before starting any new growth-serum regimen.
Product examples and user experiences
Real-world feedback often highlights favorites across brands and formulas. For instance, Stila Huge Extreme Lash Mascara, L’Oreal Telescopic Mascara, Lancome Hypnose Drama Mascara, and others come up in conversations about length, volume, and lasting power. Some users also layer a white mascara primer underneath to add fullness and prevent drooping, noting that the black mascara over white is dramatically enhanced for a fuller look.
Tips for lash extension users
When using mascara with lash extensions, specific directions advise applying only to natural lashes or to the extension lashes as appropriate, removing excess product from the wand, and following maintenance routines specified by the lash professional. For removal, use gentle tools and products designed for lash extensions to avoid disturbing the extensions or lash line.
How to Apply Mascara Like a Pro
In summary, choosing the right mascara depends on your lash type and goals-whether that means length, curl, or volume. Waterproof options offer staying power under moisture, while careful application and proper removal protect lash health. A nourishing regime, both topically and through diet, can support long-term lash growth and strength.